Cohn Lifland Pearlman Herrmann & Knopf LLP
Call Today:

Liability for Not Stopping the Bus?

Copy-of-Fotolia_80752093_L-768x512.jpgWhile riding on a NJ Transit bus, Anasia Maison alleged that her fellow passengers became increasingly unruly with her and then injured her by throwing a glass object at her face. In addition to suing the passenger who threw the object, Maison alleged that NJ Transit had a duty to maintain security on the bus, keep her safe and free from harm and take reasonable steps to prevent the incident and her injuries from occurring. NJ Transit responded that it was not liable to Maison based on the immunity provisions of the NJ Tort Claims Act (the "TCA").

After conflicting decisions by two lower court judges, the Appellate Division concluded that NJ Transit was not entitled to be dismissed from the suit with prejudice. The court agreed with NJ Transit that plaintiff's claim of a duty to maintain security on the bus was barred by the police protection provision of the TCA and must be dismissed. The court also noted that plaintiff's allegations of a duty to keep her safe and free from harm and take reasonable steps to prevent the incident from occurring also may be barred by the TCA.

However, plaintiff argued on appeal that the bus driver could have taken other steps to end the harassment, such as asking the passengers to stop, calling the police and/or stopping the bus. While the court was skeptical about the validity of the first two steps in light of the police protection immunity, it seem more interested in the third, that is, stopping the bus might have allowed plaintiff to escape or obtain assistance. Because these steps were not alleged in plaintiff's complaint, the appellate court ruled that plaintiff could file an amended complaint against NJ Transit alleging those steps, as well as the additional allegation that NJ Transit is liable as a common carrier.

As the Appellate Division declined to resolve plaintiff's new allegations, we will have to await further rulings in this case to see if NJ Transit ultimately bears liability for Maison's injuries.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

No Firm In Northern New Jersey Has More Experience Than We Do. Call 201-845-9600 Today To Put Our Knowledge On Your Side.

Email Us For a Response

Contact Northern New Jersey's Premiere Law Firm

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Cohn Lifland Pearlman Herrmann & Knopf LLP
Park 80 West-Plaza One
250 Pehle Avenue
Suite 401
Saddle Brook, NJ 07663

Phone: 201-845-9600
Fax: 201-845-9423
Saddle Brook Law Office Map

Review Us